Using AI to Identify & Help Struggling Students | Dell (2024)

By Marty Graham, Contributor

College instructors have long used web-based learning management systems to virtually deliver reading material, exercises, and assignments to students. But they’ve only just begun to look at these delivery systems—and the data trails users leave behind—for clues about how students are really doing.

The results are powerful.

By leveraging artificial intelligence (AI) to analyze and find patterns in the massive data sets, college officials can identify students who are struggling and likely to drop out. For instance, they would see how many times a student visited an online lesson and then suddenly stopped. With quick intervention by advisors, the schools can then track and measure the students’ improvements and successes.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: Evolving Technologies Make STEM Learning Fun

At the University of Nevada Las Vegas (UNLV), Professor Matt Bernacki (who’s now at the University of North Carolina) pioneered such efforts as part of his postgraduate work in educational psychology.

“I set out to study learning by using the clicks, highlights, and annotations students make when they read,” Bernacki says. “Then I dug into the learning management system to confirm a suspicion: If students have to access their learning materials from university servers, then those servers have to receive those clicks in order to return the material the student requests.”

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE THIS PODCAST ON EDUCATION

Once Bernacki began looking into those clicks, he was able to produce an untapped resource for understanding and improving learning.

The results from these experiments are dramatic. UNLV’s initial program was so successful that it won a National Science Foundation grant in 2018 for nearly $1 million, funds that would be used to figure out how to keep students in science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) programs. (According to the university, 40 percent of declared STEM majors abandon the major once they face the challenging coursework.)

Meanwhile, Arizona State University employed learning systems data to identify and help struggling freshmen in 2016. The results: a 15 percent increase in the number of first-year students who stay for the second year, with important increases in retaining low-income and first-generation students.

When experts talk about continued examples of success, they often point to Georgia State University, where administrators have intervened to connect students to advisors 500,000 times since the school began looking at navigation data in 2012, according to senior vice president for student success Timothy Renick. “Our graduation rates are up 62 percent and we are graduating 3,000 more students annually than we were before,” he says.

Ousting the Trial by Fire

Students have long been expected to fend for themselves, and systems were set up with that mindset, says UNLV Provost Carl Reiber. “That trial-by-fire mentality was all wrong. We’re here to teach students, not weed them out of their futures. It’s an approach that’s been proven harmful to first-generation students and underrepresented minorities, in particular.”

“That trial-by-fire mentality was all wrong. We’re here to teach students, not weed them out of their futures.”

—Carl Reiber, provost, University of Nevada Las Vegas

Web-based learning management systems first appeared in the 1990s, and by 2003 were the norm rather than the exception. But the systems focused primarily on delivering lessons to students, not observing their interactions. Meanwhile, the features used by college staff were mainly for administrative matters. Today, the systems’ big data can identify the obvious, like failing courses at midterm, but also more nuanced issues.

“What’s interesting about our use of big data is its ability to uncover less obvious early signs of trouble,” Renick says. “For instance, even a passing grade of ‘C’ can be an indicator of significant risk when the grade is in a course critical to the student’s field of study or the first grade a student takes in his or her major.”

“We have also identified ‘toxic combinations,’ two courses that, if the student takes in the same semester, produce much higher failure rates [based on past data] than if the courses are taken in different semesters,” Renick adds. For example, students may do just fine in physics and organic chemistry classes, but not in the same semester, he notes.

Repurposing Students’ Data Is Still Novel

“We’re shifting from the purpose of the data being administrative to data being used to help the students,” says James Wiley, principal analyst for the National Research Center for College and University Admissions.

“We’re shifting from the purpose of the data being administrative to data being used to help the students.”

—James Wiley, principal analyst, National Research Center for College and University Admissions

Wiley has encouraged vendors to invert the platforms’ goals by rethinking the basis for the algorithms they’re designing.

“The question for designing the algorithms is what action do you want to take? What end result do you want to achieve and then think backwards,” he says. “Then you think about getting the right data, contextualizing it, displaying it and learning from it and gaining some wisdom.”

But for all the magic of the technology, the students’ success still comes down to connecting advisors to help—and this requires finesse, says Columbia University communications manager Elizabeth “Lisa” Ganga.“It’s tricky, we have to avoid sending the wrong kind of message, one that the student might understand as I’m doing poorly and might as well drop out.” The human touch matters, and may be the most important part, she stresses.

“You can have the algorithms flag the students and then you need to have the advisors ready to assist these students.”

—Elizabeth “Lisa” Ganga, communications manager, Columbia University

“Part of making these interventions work involves retraining advisors to move faster and have more resources to offer right away,” Ganga continues. “You can have the algorithms flag the students and then you need to have the advisors ready to assist these students.”

Like most experiments, plumbing student data has a learning curve that’s based on measuring its impact.

“Measuring outcomes will give you a sense of humility,” Wiley says. “It’s a hand-holding journey and you have to be prepared to iterate along this journey. Data will change. Patterns will change. Tools will change.”

The need for students to succeed, however, will remain constant.

Using AI to Identify & Help Struggling Students | Dell (2024)

FAQs

Using AI to Identify & Help Struggling Students | Dell? ›

By leveraging artificial intelligence (AI) to analyze and find patterns in the massive data sets, college officials can identify students who are struggling and likely to drop out. For instance, they would see how many times a student visited an online lesson and then suddenly stopped.

How can AI be used to help students? ›

AI in schools helps students by offering personalized learning experiences. By analyzing data on each student's strengths and weaknesses, AI can create customized learning plans that cater to each student's needs. This means that each student receives the support and guidance they need to achieve their full potential.

How could AI be used to make learning more effective and personalized? ›

AI in education is increasingly being used to personalise learning experiences for students. It provides tailored educational content based on their skills, interests, and learning styles. AI analyses student performance data and identifies patterns of learning difficulties or gaps in understanding.

How AI can help in understanding educational needs? ›

AI facilitates student access to high-quality educational resources, regardless of economic status or geographic location. AI can assess each student's progress and provide real-time feedback, helping them identify their strengths and areas for improvement.

What impact is AI having on education that is important to identify and address? ›

Data-driven insights: AI provides educators with valuable data-driven insights into student performance and learning patterns. This information helps in making informed decisions, refining teaching strategies, and identifying areas that may require additional attention.

Is AI good or bad for education? ›

One of the biggest cons of AI in education is that it can dehumanize the learning experience. With AI algorithms generating content and deciding the pacing of the lessons, students may miss out on the nuanced approach that a human teacher can offer.

What are the positive impacts of AI on students? ›

Overall, the positive impact of AI on students includes personalized instruction, enhanced critical thinking skills, and better preparation for the evolving demands of the digital age, contributing to a more dynamic and adaptive educational experience.

How do teachers use AI in the classroom? ›

The Most Common AI Tools Used in the Classroom

Teachers use AI-powered educational games more often than any other AI tools, but adaptive learning platforms and automated grading and feedback systems are also popular.

How AI can help students with learning disabilities? ›

These algorithms analyze individual strengths and weaknesses, customizing instructional content to accommodate diverse learning styles. Through interactive exercises, gamification, and multisensory approaches, AI engages users in ways traditional methods cannot, making the learning process enjoyable and effective.

What are the disadvantages of AI for students? ›

A disadvantage of AI in education is the potential for ethical and privacy concerns. AI systems collect and analyze a significant amount of data on students, including their performance, behavior, and personal information.

What AI helps in education? ›

Gradescope is an innovative online platform that transforms how educators assess student work. It streamlines the entire grading process while offering valuable insights into learning. Moreover, the tool uses the power of AI to make grading faster, more efficient, and more consistent.

How does AI make education more accessible? ›

AI helps to make learning more accessible and personalized. For example, for a student who is blind or low vision, AI can help them access information with screen readers. Technology like PDF OCR in Chrome browser extracts text from PDFs so screen readers can read them out loud.

Can AI replace teachers? ›

The answer is nuanced. While AI can address the issue of bad teachers and enhance the capabilities of good ones, it cannot replace the essential human connection and mentorship that teachers provide. Likewise, tutors who genuinely care about their students' success will continue to be indispensable.

How can AI help me study? ›

For example, AI tools can be used to:
  1. Generate practice quizzes or flashcards to help you prepare for exams.
  2. Quickly learn more about a new subject or topic.
  3. Tutor yourself to improve your language skills.
  4. Interact with virtual tutors.
  5. Create study guides.

How can AI help education in the future? ›

Artificial intelligence (AI) can support education by automating administrative tasks, freeing teachers to focus more on teaching and personalized interactions with students, enhancing rather than replacing human-led teaching.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Greg Kuvalis

Last Updated:

Views: 6008

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Greg Kuvalis

Birthday: 1996-12-20

Address: 53157 Trantow Inlet, Townemouth, FL 92564-0267

Phone: +68218650356656

Job: IT Representative

Hobby: Knitting, Amateur radio, Skiing, Running, Mountain biking, Slacklining, Electronics

Introduction: My name is Greg Kuvalis, I am a witty, spotless, beautiful, charming, delightful, thankful, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.